Skip to main content
IACM 2022

IACM 2022 Abstract Book »

Overprecision in the Survey of Professional Forecasters


Keywords: overconfidence, economic forecasts, policy, cognitive bias, behavioral economics, judgment, decision making

Abstract: Every decision depends on a forecast of its consequences. We examine the calibration of the single longest and most complete forecasting project. The Survey of Professional Forecasters has, since 1968, elicited predictions of key economic indicators such as unemployment, inflation, and economic growth. Here, we test the accuracy of those forecasts (n = 12,359) and measure the degree to which they fall victim to overconfidence, both overoptimism and overprecision. We find forecasts are overly precise; forecasters report 53% confidence in the accuracy of their forecasts, but are correct only 28% of the time. By contrast, forecasts show little evidence of optimistic bias. We employ a novel split sample methodology in analyzing archival data, creating exploration and validation halves.

Sandy Campbell, University of California Berkeley (United States)
Email: sandyca@berkeley.edu

Don Moore, University of California Berkeley (United States)
Email: dm@berkeley.edu

 


Powered by OpenConf®
Copyright ©2002-2021 Zakon Group LLC